background image

' SLS loudspeakers Inc., 2002. All rights reserved.

1

RLA 1 Ribbon Line Array

The unique technology behind a truly coherent line array for high

fidelity professional sound systems

Introduction

Line array loudspeaker systems have recently received a high level of attention and have
even become fashionable, revolutionizing the very basics of professional sound
applications. Although the general concept of line arrays is not new, the contemporary
incarnations of this principle represent significantly different loudspeaker systems. This
new generation of line array systems aims to benefit from very specific radiation
properties, exhibited by an ideal line source radiator. A line source radiator has unique
and highly desirable features such as: lower SPL reduction with distance than a normal
system and far superior dispersion control in the vertical plane (if the line is oriented
vertically). These unique characteristics render line arrays as a separate and unique class
of loudspeaker systems.

In spite of their growing popularity in professional and consumer markets, there is a
definite complexity in the design and proper application of these systems. A line array that
allows for maximum utilization of the benefits of a line source radiator would become a
powerful and very efficient tool for the industry. However, a certain degree of
misconception of some basic line array principles and specifics is still common. As a
result, some of the currently marketed line array systems have quite questionable
performance benefits and lower than expected sound quality.

 It must be stressed, that in addition to these misconceptions, horn loaded compression
driver technology imposes certain limitations, preventing manufacturers from developing
high performance line arrays with truly coherent dispersion. In order to fully benefit from
the implementation of the line source concept, a line array system must incorporate
transducers arranged in a continuous line that produces a coherent planar wavefront
along the entire array. In order to simulate a continuous planar wavefront, a line array
design must abandon the concept of simple vertical stack of compression drivers
terminated with horns. This requires a radical change in horn design techniques used for
decades. However, this is hardly possible due to the very principle of compression driver
operation. As a solution, all current designs eventually accept various compromises and
incorporate a host of extended sound conduits, phase plugs, fins and various acoustical
delay devices. This, according to a manufacturers’ literature, supposedly directs and
squeezes sound waves into a predetermined shape, with an output wavefront which
should eventually resemble a continuous line or planar radiator at the mouth of integrated
horn.
The truth is, that the laws of sound propagation are much more complex than a flow of a
liquid through pipes, and one can not endlessly reshape sound waves without distorting
the original.  All this “treatment” further complicates the transition of sound waves in such
systems, producing very audible distortion. The necessity to use horn loading at high
frequencies is in contradiction with the need of close spacing of midrange drivers for wide
and consistent horizontal dispersion. Therefore midrange drivers in turn are also forced
into various types of arrangements. In some line array designs they are hidden deep

Summary of Contents for RLA 1

Page 1: ... addition to these misconceptions horn loaded compression driver technology imposes certain limitations preventing manufacturers from developing high performance line arrays with truly coherent dispersion In order to fully benefit from the implementation of the line source concept a line array system must incorporate transducers arranged in a continuous line that produces a coherent planar wavefro...

Page 2: ...lation of the very essential near field and transition regions of a line array but rather describe its performance based on a far field model used for common point source systems Recognizing this need SLS Loudspeakers developed the LASS Line Array Simulator Software program It is an accurate software tool which allows for simulation of line array dispersion and prediction of sound field parameters...

Page 3: ...g 3 will produce much smaller difference in SPL levels throughout the venue with SPL being significantly lower in close proximity to the source 18 dB 1m versus 30 dB for the point source This provides very comfortable listening conditions without the danger of overpowering the audience in the front rows cylindrical wavefront provides very controlled energy dispersion in the plane which coincides w...

Page 4: ...s a space taken by each driver or distance between driver centers The condition that defines a discrete line array as a line source can be related to two different shapes of the radiating element It is shown 1 that for circular drivers proper line source behavior or coupling can be achieved in a frequency range where H λ where λ is a wavelength at a given frequency For example to fulfill this cond...

Page 5: ...g waveguides also introduce significant distortion in addition to the distortion inherent to compression drivers Design B uses another approach Two compression drivers have sectored waveguides that supposedly generate a plane wave at the output by slicing a wave into thin segments and producing a line of secondary sound sources at the output Instead due to their different lengths there is a progre...

Page 6: ...rely compromised Line array application techniques require at least 90 nominal horizontal dispersion at 6 dB in order to maintain consistent coverage in wide venues Fig 6 depicts driver arrangement techniques used in line arrays for satisfying these requirements The picture clearly demonstrates the advantages of ribbon driver based design The presence of the ribbon line source element in front of ...

Page 7: ...e arrays is 16 8 feet and a simulation field is extended to 150 feet Dark lines represent hypothetical listening planes LASS allows for generation of SPL distribution diagrams along these planes The particular line arrangement depicted below illustrates SPL coverage consistency along the venue on the axis of the arrays and across the coverage zone along the line parallel to the array at a distance...

Page 8: ...line array no splay 4 kHz Top graph SPL along the horizontal line Bottom graph SPL across the vertical line Fig 8 10 element line array with 75 of radiating surface per element no splay 4 kHz Top graph SPL along the horizontal line Bottom graph SPL across the vertical line ...

Page 9: ...n a real situation such deviations would be clearly noticeable leaving a significant portion of the audience with almost no high frequency information and in some cases rendering certain areas within the venue lacking in intelligibility It is very important to preserve the overall SPL and spectral balance at each frequency throughout the coverage zone RLA 1 provides significantly better performanc...

Page 10: ...repancy between line array polar diagrams If we were able to measure polar diagrams of a 3 m long line source at 5 50 and 500 meters we would observe different polar diagrams for different distances Therefore a line array dispersion diagram observed along the array s length in the simplest case this would be vertical dispersion is a particular characteristic for a particular distance In other word...

Page 11: ... LASS allows for quick and accurate calculation of line array vertical dispersion Below is a series of measured and calculated graphs of the RLA 1 ribbon line array All measurements and calculations where performed for the 8 element RLA1 at a distance of 66 feet 20m The RLA1 3D dispersion waterfall was measured prior to constructing 2D plots and comparing the results with computer simulated plots ...

Page 12: ...ource It is a misconception that a line array has the vertical dispersion larger than 0 In practice a coupled line array has 0 vertical dispersion The SPL drops approximately by 6dB at the ends of the projected corridor with very steep SPL reduction away from the coverage zone Fig 16 and Fig 17 depict a family of normalized to the central on axis microphone position frequency response curves for e...

Page 13: ...RLA1 0 splay Family of frequency response curves measured along the measurement line across the coverage area at 66ft Fig 17 8 element RLA1 5 splay between elements Family of frequency response curves measured along the measurement line across the coverage area at 66ft ...

Page 14: ...sponse is remarkably consistent and smooth within the main portion of the coverage up to 5 kHz with some deviations above this point Fig 18 depicts another interesting and very useful relationship the difference between measured frequency response of the straight RLA1 and the curved RLA1 with 5 splay between each element The microphone was placed in the middle of the coverage zone on symmetry axis...

Page 15: ... sound quality but more importantly provides a much more reliable system with less hardware and shorter rigging time The LASS program allows for quick and vivid display of performance parameters such as SPL curves along the listening lines Using a comprehensive iterative process it is easy to design the optimum line array system for a given application As an example two RLA 1 line array configurat...

Page 16: ... average levels throughout the venue The resulting system provides remarkably consistent coverage at only 10 dB SPL in mentioned 65ft 164 ft area and beyond up to the farthest seats yielding total 5 dB SPL deviation throughout the entire venue It is worth noting that both systems have the same number of elements and the same total vertical coverage angle Hardly any level shading or other DSP proce...

Page 17: ...to line arrays since it is valid only if measured in a system s far field A line array s dispersion diagram observed along the array s length in the simplest case this would be vertical dispersion is a specific characteristic for a specific distance If measured it is only valid for the distance at which the test was performed A dispersion diagram should be measured along the polygonal measurement ...

Page 18: ...he only method feasible for accurate prediction is the combination of LASS simulation data in vertical plane with measured data of one array element in the horizontal plane Using interpolation techniques and both types of data it would be possible to generate a directivity balloon which would be the closest approximation to a real system Author Igor Levitsky Many thanks go to Tom Harrison for help...

Reviews: